Twin deficits hypothesis

In macroeconomics, the twin deficits hypothesis or the twin deficits phenomenon, is the proposition that there is a strong causal link between a nations government budget balance and its current account balance.

1. Definition
Standard macroeconomic theory points to how a budget deficit can be a contributing factor to a current account deficit. This link can be seen from considering the national accounting model of the economy:
Y = C + I + G + X − M, {\displaystyle Y=C+I+G+X-M,}
where Y represents national income or GDP, C is consumption, I is investment, G is government spending and X–M stands for net exports. This represents GDP because all the production in an economy the left hand side of the equation is used as consumption C, investment I, government spending G, and goods that are exported in excess of imports NX. Another equation defining GDP using alternative terms which in theory results in the same value is
Y = C + S + T, {\displaystyle Y=C+S+T,}
where Y is again GDP, C is consumption, is saving, and T is taxes. This is because national income is also equal to output, and all individual income either goes to pay for consumption C, to pay taxes T, or is saved S.

2. Proof
Since Y = C + I + G + N X {\displaystyle Y=C+I+G+NX}, and
Y − C − T = S {\displaystyle Y-C-T=S}, then
S = G − T + N X + I {\displaystyle S=G-T+NX+I}, which simplifies to the sectoral balances identity
S − I + T − G = N X {\displaystyle S-I+T-G=NX}
If T-G is negative, we have a budget deficit.
Now, assume an economy already at potential output, meaning Y is fixed. In this case, if the deficit increases, and saving remains the same, then this last equation implies that either investment I must fall see crowding out, or net exports NX must fall, causing a trade deficit. Hence, a budget deficit can also lead to a trade deficit, causing a twin deficit.
Though the economics behind which of the two is used to finance the government deficit can get more complicated than what is shown above, the essence of it is that if foreigners savings pay for the budget deficit, the current account deficit grows. If the countrys own citizens savings finance the borrowing, it may cause a crowding out effect in an economy at or near potential output, or full employment.

3. Example
In the US, the budget deficit is financed about half from foreigners, half domestically. Therefore, with an additional $400 billion deficit, the trade deficit would, according to the theory, be increased by some $200 billion.
An economy is deemed to have a double deficit if it has a current account deficit and a fiscal deficit. In effect, the economy is borrowing from foreigners in exchange for foreign-made goods. Traditional macroeconomics predicts that persistent double deficits will lead to currency devaluation/depreciation that can be severe and sudden.
In the case of the United States, the twin deficit graph as a percentage of GDP shows that the budget and current account deficits did move broadly in sync from 1981 until the early 1990s, but since then, they have moved apart. Data thus confirm that as a government budget deficit widens, the current account falls, but the relationship is complicated by what happens to investment and private saving.
C A = S − I + T − G {\displaystyle CA=S-I+T-G} Current Account = Private Saving – Investment + Taxes levied – Government Expenditure
In the above equation, it is verifiable that CA will deteriorate as government expenditure exceeds the amount of tax is collected.
One way to understand this process intuitively is by thinking through two different markets. First consider the Foreign Exchange market. At equilibrium the quantity supplied = the quantity demanded. Thus, Imports + Capital outflow = Exports + Capital Inflow. Rearranging this equation we find that Imports – Exports = Capital Inflow – Capital Outflow. Because Imports – Exports = Trade Deficit and Capital Inflow – Capital Outflow = Net Capital Inflow, we get the equation Trade Deficit = Net Capital Inflow or Current Account deficit = Capital Account Surplus.
Next we must consider the market for loanable funds. The equilibrium here is Saving + Net Capital Inflow = Investment + Budget Deficit. However, taking the Forex market into consideration we know that the Trade Deficit is equal to Net Capital Inflow. We can thus substitute for:
Saving + Trade Deficit = Investment + Budget Deficit.
Rearranging algebraically we find that:
Budget Deficit = Saving + Trade Deficit – Investment.
What we can gather from this is the understanding of why an increased budget deficit goes up and down in tandem with the Trade Deficit. This is where we derive the appellation the Twin Deficits: if the US budget deficit goes up then either household savings must go up, the trade deficit must go up, or private investment will decrease.

memory, and deficits in long - term recall appear to be attributed to impairments in working memory. The criteria for an executive function deficit are met
including automatization deficits of both skill and knowledge acquisition, balance impairments, motor skill writing deficits and muscle tone underdevelopment
The lead crime hypothesis is the proposed link between elevated blood lead levels in children and increased rates of crime, delinquency, and recidivism
link of SCT to EF deficits is clearly indicated - but, as of this time, SCT does not seem to be as strongly associated with EF deficits as is ADHD. Unlike
hippocampal volume was 19.5 smaller than that of his twin His teachers reported continued deficits in memory function, new learning efficiency, verbal
including attention deficits Neither negative symptoms, such as problems with social interaction, or hippocampus - related deficits are observed in amphetamine
with Paul Craig Roberts The Conventional Hypothesis Deficit Estimates, Savings Rates, Twin Deficits and Yield Curves U.S. Treasury 2004 The
Tourette s and attention - deficit hyperactivity disorder ADHD is not yet fully understood. Genetic studies, including twin studies, have proven that
A. 2012 A multivariate twin study of autistic traits in 12 - year - olds: testing the fractionable autism triad hypothesis Behavior Genetics, 42, 245 - 255
reported, however. Hunter vs. farmer hypothesis Neurodiversity Low arousal theory - Alternate theory of ADHD Attention - deficit hyperactivity disorder controversies